We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.

logo
  • Engineers & Specifiers
  • Contractors & Installers
  • Wholesalers & Distributors
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Free Subscription
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • PRODUCTS
    • Bath & Kitchen
    • Fire Protection
    • HVAC
    • Hydronics/Radiant
    • Plumbing
    • PVF
    • Tools
  • PROJECTS
    • Commercial
    • Green Building
    • MRO/Retrofit
    • Remodeling
    • Residential
  • HOW TO
    • Design
    • Fire Protection
    • Legal Matters
    • Management
  • BUSINESS
    • Buying Groups
    • Technology
    • Associations
  • CODES & STANDARDS
    • ANSI
    • ASHRAE
    • ASSE
    • Regulations
    • Green Building
    • IAPMO
    • ICC
    • NFPA
  • RESOURCES
    • Media Kit
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Classifieds
    • Digital Editions
    • Behind the Wall
    • Webinars
    • AHR Live 2023
  • PODCASTS
  • DIGITAL EDITIONS
Home » The Problem with Mentorship
Business Uncomplicated

The Problem with Mentorship

Mentors can fast-track your success. However, they are not perfect, or magic or even senior to your own knowingness.

January 4, 2021
Ellen Rohr
No Comments
phc01_ellen

I’ve been in this awesome industry for a long time. I’ve put in the 10,000 hours and then some. Gratefully, I am more excited than ever about what is to come. 

Much of my confidence comes from the great lessons I’ve learned from mentors along the way. I’ve also gained so much from helping others start, fix and grow businesses. And I’ve learned lots of lessons the hard way by just muddling through — and have the scars to prove it.

Mentors can fast-track your success. However, they are not perfect, or magic or even senior to your own knowingness. I’m offering the following tips for mentors and mentees in gratitude to the wonderful mentors I have had and the outstanding leaders for whom I have had the privilege of “holding their beer.” 

Be picky

When it comes to finding mentors, it’s best to watch and listen before reaching out. Has this person accomplished something you want to do or achieved demonstrable success in an area of life with which you struggle? Do a little research — listen to their podcasts, Google-search them and dig into their LinkedIn profiles. Watch for integrity between what they say and what they do. 

One of the reasons Frank Blau is such a great mentor to me is that he evidenced the success of his business strategy. Frank showed his W-2s from the presentation stage. Hard to resist that kind of credibility. 

I found Frank by writing him a letter, responding to one of his columns. In my letter, I told him he was dead wrong. He called me in spite of my awkward first approach and set me straight. I cherish his mentorship and teach what I’ve learned from him about financial strategy every day. 

Some mentors I found serendipitously. I met Al Levi through our mutual friend and mentor, Dan Holohan, and Al introduced me to Jim Criniti. These savvy businessmen have become my best friends and trusted partners. 

Other mentors, I pursued. I started an online radio show about 10 years ago — now called a podcast — with the express purpose of talking to business people whom I’d studied and admired. That’s how I met Jack Stack and Brian Scudamore and scores of other brilliant minds. Having those conversations is one of the motivations for the PHCPPros Behind the Wall podcast series (www.phcppros.com/behind_the_wall). 

Mentors are human

When you find a mentor, be careful not to put him or her on a pedestal. Once upon a time, I was at a “big table” meeting with the executives of a large industry conglomerate. The senior executive at the table was a mentor of mine, and I held him in high regard. 

During the meeting, he turned to one of his vice presidents and started to berate him. He raised his voice, called him names and rattled off a list of his transgressions. The receiving party recoiled but took it as the rest of us silently watched, eyes wide and jaws dropped. I was gobsmacked at the unprofessional behavior. 

After the meeting, I found one of the other attendees and expressed my concerns to him: “What just happened? Why is it OK that he got abused like that in front of us? Should I have jumped in and defended him?” He responded: “Ellen, you have been operating under the assumption your mentor is perfect. He’s not. He’s human.” 

That landed hard. I elevated this man, and other mentors in my life, to a level above the rest of us mere mortals. Now I am more sympathetic to my mentors. I accept that they are flawed as well as gifted and still have much to offer. 

Mentorship backflows 

If I am to extend compassion to my mentors, I must allow it for myself, too. As a mentee and a mentor, I am going to make mistakes. Too many times, I have asked for help, then refused it. Or argued as to why the wisdom wouldn’t apply to my life or situation. 

It’s OK to resist or refuse advice. However, I discovered that it is helpful to listen when I ask a question. And try things if what I am doing isn’t working very well — even if they are out of my comfort zone. 

However, sometimes your mentor is just flat-out wrong. Or what once worked no longer works. The best mentoring relationships flow back and forth. Your opinion is not worth less than your mentors; it’s just colored by your experience — not theirs. A good mentor will welcome the dialogue. 

Another thing: I’ve had people call or email me to thank me or correct me on some advice I’ve given either directly or from a stage or in a column. Sometimes, what they tell me I said, I don’t remember saying or ever believing. In other words, what you mean to communicate doesn’t always land the way you intended. Just sayin’. 

Make standards standard 

Over the years, I have changed what I will tolerate of myself and others. While I am more compassionate, I am also less blindly tolerant. This is a paradox, not a contradiction. 

I no longer tolerate the bullying and “mansplaining” that I once did. Too often I stood silently while a highly regarded, successful person behaved badly. Calling a “time out'' can allow the offender to correct course. At the very least, it lets the people in the room know that you consider the behavior unacceptable. 

There are plenty of times I behaved badly, too. Most of the time, I was trying to be funny and crossed the line to hurtful. I must be willing to be called out on my behavior, too, and now encourage my team to do so. 

Standards are defined by right action and corrective action. Apologizing is not a sign of weakness. Standing up for each other can be a mentoring moment. 

One of my commitments is to help more women find success in our awesome industry. In years past, I have been oblivious to the unique challenges of women, people of color and minorities in the PHCP world. We’ve got a long way to go to level up, and mentorship is a worthy path to travel. It’s why I am highlighting so many extraordinary women in our Behind the Wall podcasts. 

Give credit and expect none 

Most of the mentors I know appreciate it when you appreciate them. If you took their advice to heart, let them know the results and your gratitude. As a mentor, keep in mind what a mentor once told me: “When your clients fail, it’s your fault. When they succeed, it’s theirs.” He didn’t mean it as a warning but as a prescription. Let them have the win. 

So often, mentorship evolves into connecting people in your contacts list. “Oh, I know someone who is in a similar situation. Let me introduce you!” Healthy mentorship evolves into friendship, and that’s pretty cool. 

Seek advice from those who have been where you want to go and done what you want to do. Then, pull that counsel through your own filter and make your own decision. You’re the boss of you. Sometimes the long way there is the most valuable. And some mentors, well, you just outgrow. Like other relationships in your life, mentoring relationships can run their course. 

In business and in life, sometimes you need a hand and sometimes you can offer one. 

Business Management Marketing
  • Related Articles

    The Executive Problem With E-Commerce

    Taming the Problem Child: A Look at Sales Ego

    STEEL: Ahhh…The Real Problem

  • Related Products

    The Wholesaler

    Directory Listing - Premium

    CEU Webinar

  • Related Events

    PVF Roundtable Dinner with Terry Bradshaw

    Council for Research on Distributor Best Practices “Digitizing the Sales Process” Consortium

Ellen rohr
Ellen Rohr

Is sleep the new sex?

More from this author
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Most Popular

  • Chicago Plumber’s Union Dyes Chicago River Green for St. Patrick’s Day 2023

  • Everything You Wanted to Know About Orangeburg Pipe (But Were Afraid To Ask)

  • Vote Now! Plumbing Design of the Year: A Readers’ Choice Award

  • The Basis for Most Plumbing Codes

Featured Video

Caleffi video thumb

The Gold Standard: Separation with NO Compromise

Industry Events

  • 26Mar

    MCAA 2023 Annual Convention

    Phoenix, AZ
  • 29Mar

    2023 SFPE European Conference & Expo

    Berlin ,
  • 11Apr

    ASA ELEVATE2023

    Charleston, SC
More Events

Subscribe to our newsletters & stay updated

Subscribe & Learn More

  • Tw03 2023 cover
    Learn More
  • Pe03 2023 cover
    Learn More
  • Phc03 2023 cover
    Learn More
  • Es 2022
    Learn More
Subscribe

More from PHCP Pros

  • Editorial Team
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise

Follow Us

© 2023 All Rights Reserved

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development | ePublishing