We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.

logo
  • Engineers & Specifiers
  • Contractors & Installers
  • Wholesalers & Distributors
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Free Subscription
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • PRODUCTS
    • Bath & Kitchen
    • Fire Protection
    • HVAC
    • Hydronics/Radiant
    • Plumbing
    • PVF
    • Tools
  • PROJECTS
    • Commercial
    • Green Building
    • MRO/Retrofit
    • Remodeling
    • Residential
  • HOW TO
    • Design
    • Fire Protection
    • Legal Matters
    • Management
  • BUSINESS
    • Buying Groups
    • Technology
    • Associations
  • CODES & STANDARDS
    • ANSI
    • ASHRAE
    • ASSE
    • Regulations
    • Green Building
    • IAPMO
    • ICC
    • NFPA
  • RESOURCES
    • PROS REPS
    • Media Kit
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Classifieds
    • Digital Editions
    • Behind the Wall
    • Webinars
    • AHR Live 2023
  • PODCASTS
  • DIGITAL EDITIONS
Home » Boltex and Weldbend Win Jury Verdict in Lawsuit Against Ulma

Boltex and Weldbend Win Jury Verdict in Lawsuit Against Ulma

September 30, 2019
Boltex and Weldbend Win Jury Verdict in Lawsuit Against Ulma for False Advertising and Unfair Competition

On Sept. 27, a jury returned a verdict in favor of Boltex and Weldbend on all counts in a lawsuit by the American carbon steel flange manufacturers, against a Spanish company, Ulma Forja – part of the Mondragon Corp. – and its U.S. subsidiary, Ulma Piping. The trial, which began on Sept. 16, was presided over by Judge Andrew S. Hanen in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas, Houston Division.

Boltex, based in Houston, and Weldbend, headquartered outside of Chicago, became suspicious several years ago when Ulma began offering supposedly heat-treated (“normalized”) flanges to U.S. customers at undercutting prices. Plaintiffs sued Ulma in 2017, after metallurgical testing suggested that Ulma’s flanges had not been normalized and were not in conformance with industry standards as claimed by Ulma’s advertising.

The lawsuit accused Ulma of falsely claiming that it normalized its flanges in accordance with American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) A105 standards. It further stated that Ulma stamped these flanges “A105N”, issued documentation with each flange stating they had undergone the normalization process specified by the ASTM and continued to ship the flanges into the United States for use in American pipelines, refineries and chemical plants ─ all when testing showed the flanges were not normalized.

“We are very pleased with the jury’s verdict in this case and their findings that Ulma engaged in false advertising and unfair competition, which harmed two American companies and their workers,” said Frank Bernobich, chairman and president of Boltex.

“I want to thank the jury for recognizing Ulma’s unfair and deceptive practices that have gone on for years,” said James Coulas Jr., president of Weldbend. "American companies like Weldbend and Boltex can compete with anyone in the world on a fair and level playing field.”

Boltex and Weldbend were represented by partners Saul Perloff and Marc Collier of Norton Rose Fulbright and Carmine Zarlenga of Mayer Brown. 

Business Codes & Standards Industry Community News Legal Plumbing PVF Safety Wholesalers & Distributors
  • Related Articles

    Weldbend and Boltex Prevail as Federal Court Orders Recall of Ulma's "Dangerous" Pipeline Flanges

    Jury Awards Homeowner $1.75 million in Lawsuit Against Plumber and Homebuilder

    Jury awards Montana woman $1.75 million in lawsuit against home builder, plumbing company​

Most Popular

  • DiversiTech to Acquire Pro1 Thermostats

  • Lion Plumbing Supply and American Standard Join Forces to Brighten Up North Miami Neighborhood

  • Rich-Tomkins Co. Honors Industry Icon and Bradford White Water Heaters Trainer Herbert Harvey Jr.

  • Industry Mentor Morrie Beschloss Passes Away

Featured Video

Liberty video 2

Liberty Pumps Materials Center Open House with Charlie Cook

Industry Events

  • 04Jun

    NCWA Annual Convention

    French Lick, IN
  • 11Jun

    AWWA 2023 Annual Conference & Exposition (ACE23)

    Toronto, ON
  • 19Jun

    2023 NFPA Conference & Expo

    Las Vegas, NV
More Events

Subscribe to our newsletters & stay updated

Subscribe & Learn More

  • Tw05 2023 cover
    Learn More
  • Pe05 2023 cover
    Learn More
  • Phc05 2023 cover
    Learn More
  • Es 2022
    Learn More
Subscribe

More from PHCP Pros

  • Editorial Team
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise

Follow Us

© 2023 All Rights Reserved

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development | ePublishing